By It may be tempting to categorize big retailers under the same umbrella, but in reality, each industry player has its own unique story. This is particularly evident when examining the stark contrast between Walmart and Target in 2023.
Walmart: Reaping the Rewards
Shares of Walmart (ticker: WMT) have soared to record highs this month, demonstrating the fruits of the world’s largest retailer’s investments across various sectors, including grocery and technology. With a remarkable 15% increase since the beginning of the year, Walmart has outperformed both the SPDR S&P Retail ETF’s (XRT) meager sub-2% year-to-date return and the Consumer Staples Select Sector SPDR Fund’s (XLP) 4% decline.
Target: Struggling in Comparison
In sharp contrast, Target (TGT), Walmart’s closest competitor, has seen its stock plummet by 20% in 2023, currently hovering near its lowest point in the past 52 weeks. Despite lacking any specific catalysts, Target shares continue to face sell-offs, experiencing a decline of over 6% this month alone.
As experts have pointed out, there are several concerns that may be contributing to Target’s downward spiral, ranging from increasing theft incidents to political uncertainties. However, at its core, the problem likely stems from consumers’ changing needs and purchasing preferences.
The Challenge of High Prices
Although inflation may be subsiding, prices still remain stubbornly high compared to just a few years ago. This reality forces consumers to make difficult choices as essential expenses consume a larger portion of their budgets. As Larry McDonald from The Bear Traps Report stated, “Even with the Target-specific issues, this speaks to consumers shifting to the lowest-cost option.”
For some individuals, there is simply no discretionary income left after covering non-negotiables like food and shelter. The proof lies in the fact that U.S. credit card balances surpassed the $1 trillion mark this summer, indicating that more Americans are relying on debt to meet their basic needs. Meanwhile, those with some remaining disposable income find that their funds have significantly dwindled. As a result, these consumers are more likely to prioritize spending their limited fun money on services and experiences rather than replenishing the goods they stockpiled during the pandemic.
In conclusion, the divergence between Walmart and Target in 2023 represents a significant disparity in their performance and highlights the challenges retailers face amid higher prices and evolving consumer demands.
The Challenge for Target
Target, a popular retailer, is facing a difficult situation. While the company relies heavily on non-essential items like clothing and home décor, it seems to be struggling even in its core categories during the back-to-school season. According to data from Numerator, Walmart has expanded its market share in back-to-college shopping by 1.8 percentage points, while Target’s share has declined by 3.2 percentage points.
The Power of Value
Walmart, on the other hand, benefits from having more than half of its business in essential items such as food. Its reputation for low prices has attracted customers across various income levels, including those with high salaries. Analyst Corey Tarlowe from Jefferies simplifies the current retail environment by stating that “value wins”. This notion is supported by data that shows value and mass retailers consistently outperforming their peers. Walmart and Costco Wholesale are the only retailers that have achieved comparable sales growth every quarter over the past 18 quarters.
The Trend Continues
Tarlowe expects this trend to continue, driven by consumers’ desire for bargains and the rise in sales of cheaper, private-label products. Investors seem to agree, as Walmart’s stock has been steadily increasing throughout the year, while Target’s shares have been declining.
Betting on the Winners
In the stock market, investors have been focused on the “magnificent seven” big tech stocks that have played a significant role in the market rally of 2023. Similarly, when it comes to retail stocks, investors are willing to bet on just a few winners.
Comments